End-to-End Authentication Test Results

Date: November 9, 2025
Primary Scripts:

• scripts/test-e2e-auth.js
• scripts/test-checkout-urls.js
• npm run test -- checkout-success-url

Current Status

✅ Working & Verified

• /health — Production instance healthy (curl -I https://reformer-platform.onrender.com/health)
• /api/checkout — Redirects unauthenticated browser traffic to dashboard signup with preserved return URL (see Checkout Verification below)
• handleCheckout — Stripe session success_url now points to https://dash.reformer.la/?checkout=success&session_id=… (unit coverage npm run test -- checkout-success-url)
• /api/auth/me — Correctly rejects unauthenticated requests (401)

✅ Resolved (Nov 9, 2025 @ 20:30 UTC)

• Forgot password flow now uses the Supabase admin generate_link API + Resend fallback. Verified with test1@reformer.la and uat-fix1@reformer.la (emailSent: true, Render no longer reports high error rate).

✅ Completed (Nov 11, 2025)

• Password reset system fully implemented and deployed:
  • POST /api/auth/forgot-password - Sends recovery email via Resend
  • POST /api/auth/reset-password - Resets password with Supabase recovery token
  • Frontend pages: /forgot-password and /reset-password
  • Password strength validation (8+ chars, uppercase, lowercase, number)
  • Token extraction from URL hash (#access_token=xxx&type=recovery)
  • Rate limiting on both endpoints
• Email verification redirects fixed:
  • Users redirect to client portal (my.reformer.la/{clientslug}) after verification
  • Onboarding form displays on portal home page
  • Removed blocking messages that prevented onboarding access
• Close CRM automations guard missing helpers and fall back to lead creation; Render logs show updateCloseCRM: Success for all post-fix onboarding runs.
• Dropbox metadata persistence updates dropbox_link, dropbox_path, and dropbox_created_at for each new member (confirmed in Supabase for uat-fix* accounts).
• Stripe webhook endpoint now accepts signed events (returns 200) and rejects unsigned payloads with 400 — verified at 20:53 UTC using generated HMAC signature.

⚠️ Remaining Gaps

• Intercom updates still return an initial HTTP 400 before a retry logs success; needs cleanup/verification.
• Portal slug persistence — accounts.portal_slug and dashboard_slug remain NULL even though the API returns slugs.
• Pirsch analytics continues to skip because no client ID is configured (expected but noted for completeness).

Test Plan

Completed Tests ✅

1. Backend health check
2. Authentication protection (401 on unauthenticated access)

Pending Tests (Waiting for Fresh Accounts)

1. Signup with new email
2. Programmatic email verification (SUPABASE_SERVICE_ROLE_KEY)
3. Login after verification
4. Forgot password flow ✅ COMPLETE (Nov 11, 2025)
5. Password reset flow ✅ COMPLETE (Nov 11, 2025)
6. Checkout session creation with authenticated user (requires live Supabase token)
7. Logout

Next Steps

1. Wait for rate limit reset (1-2 hours)
2. Obtain test Supabase session (scripted helper WIP) for authenticated checkout verification
3. Re-run E2E auth script — node scripts/test-e2e-auth.js
4. Capture Stripe session redirect — confirm success_url in live checkout dashboard when authenticated

Manual Testing Checklist

While waiting for rate limits, manually test:

• Visit /signup page on dashboard
• Create account with unique email
• Check email for verification link
• Click verification link
• Login with verified account
• Access /dashboard (protected route)
• Test /forgot-password page ✅ COMPLETE (Nov 11, 2025)
• Test /reset-password page ✅ COMPLETE (Nov 11, 2025)
• Test checkout flow (requires login; expect dashboard redirect post-payment)

UAT Batch – November 9, 2025 @ 20:32 UTC (Post-fix)

Email	Signup / Login	Forgot Password	Onboarding Response	Automations (key outputs)	Notes
uat-fix1@reformer.la	✅	✅ emailSent: true	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/fix-one-coffee Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Fix One Coffee (10 subfolders + shared link) ClickUp ✅ project + onboarding/webflow/maintenance task lists Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Close CRM ✅ lead updated & Dropbox link propagated Google Workspace ✅ folder provisioned	dropbox_created_at persisted; activity logs record all integrations. portal_slug still NULL.
uat-fix2@reformer.la	✅	✅ (inferred)	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/fix-two-bakery Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Fix Two Bakery + link ClickUp ✅ project + 13 tasks Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Close CRM ✅ lead update Google Workspace ✅ folder provisioned	All automations succeeded; portal slug still empty.
uat-fix3@reformer.la	✅	✅ (inferred)	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/fix-three-fitness Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Fix Three Fitness + link ClickUp ✅ project + 13 tasks Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Close CRM ✅ lead update Google Workspace ✅ folder provisioned	Intercom still logs a 400 before retrying. Portal slug remains unset.

UAT Batch – November 9, 2025 @ 19:13 UTC (Pre-fix)

Email	Signup / Login	Forgot Password	Onboarding Response	Automations (key outputs)	Notes
test1@reformer.la	✅	❌ Error sending recovery email	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/test-one-coffee Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Test One Coffee (10 subfolders) ClickUp ✅ folder 90173757516 (Onboarding/Webflow/Maintenance lists + tasks) Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Pirsch ⚠️ skipped (no client ID) Close CRM ❌ searchLeads undefined Intercom ⚠️ 400 before retry success	portal_slug remained NULL; members.dropbox_link not persisted (dropbox_created_at missing); forgot-password failures triggered Render alert
test2@reformer.la	✅	❌ Error sending recovery email	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/test-two-bakery Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Test Two Bakery (10 subfolders) ClickUp ✅ folder 90173757549 (lists + tasks) Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Pirsch ⚠️ skipped Close CRM ❌ Intercom ⚠️ 400 then success	Same schema issue (dropbox_created_at); portal slug not set; initial Dropbox API 409 warnings before folder creation
test3@reformer.la	✅	❌ Error sending recovery email	Portal: https://my.reformer.la/test-three-fitness Dropbox: link ClickUp: https://app.clickup.com	Dropbox ✅ /Reformer Clients Directory/Test Three Fitness (10 subfolders) ClickUp ✅ folder 90173757576 (lists + tasks) Resend ✅ Dropbox-ready email Pirsch ⚠️ skipped Close CRM ❌ Intercom ⚠️ 400 then success	Same schema gap; portal slug not persisted; Dropbox metadata save failed; forgot-password 400

Automation Observations (Pre-fix)

• Every onboarding run created the Dropbox directory structure, generated shared links, and opened ClickUp projects with onboarding/webflow/maintenance lists (13 tasks total).
• Resend delivered the “Dropbox workspace ready” transactional email for all three accounts.
• closeCRM.searchLeads was missing, so CRM syncing and Dropbox-link propagation failed consistently.
• Pirsch integration is skipped by design due to missing credentials.
• Render triggered a high-error-rate alert because the forgot-password endpoint returned Supabase errors on every request.
• Accounts landed in status provisioning, but portal_slug stayed NULL despite the API returning slugs — still under investigation.

Checkout Verification (Nov 9, 2025)

• node scripts/test-checkout-urls.js
  • Confirms unauthenticated browser requests receive 302 → https://dash.reformer.la/signup?redirect=<encoded_request>
  • Covers /api/checkout?plan=starter|pro|enterprise|invalid and /api/checkout
• npm run test -- checkout-success-url
  • Stubs Stripe client to assert success_url now uses dashboard domain before marketing welcome handoff
• Live API test @ 18:02 UTC:
  • Created account checkout-test-20251109-1@reformer.la via /api/auth/signup (auto-verified; captured bearer token)
  • GET /api/checkout?plan=free (auth header) returned 303 → https://checkout.stripe.com/...
  • stripe checkout.sessions.retrieve → "success_url": "https://dash.reformer.la/?checkout=success&session_id={CHECKOUT_SESSION_ID}"
  • Session expired immediately after verification (POST /v1/checkout/sessions/{id}/expire)
• Next Live Step: Acquire Supabase JWT (service helper pending) to hit /api/checkout as an authenticated client and record returned Stripe session URL + success redirect behaviour end-to-end.

Environment Variables Needed

For full test suite to work:

• SUPABASE_SERVICE_ROLE_KEY - For programmatic email verification
• NEXT_PUBLIC_SUPABASE_URL - Supabase project URL
• SUPABASE_ANON_KEY - Supabase anonymous key (or NEXT_PUBLIC_SUPABASE_ANON_KEY)